How to Listen to Bird Song—Tips and Examples From The Warbler Guide

By Tom Stephenson and Scott Whittle, authors of The Warbler Guide
May 1, 2015
Prairie Warbler by Joshua Clark via Birdshare. Prairie Warbler. Photo by Joshua Clark via Birdshare.
New self-paced course: Learn How to Identify Bird Songs, Click to Learn More

Spring is here, and with it come the warblers, with their spectacular colors and beautiful songs. Unfortunately for many birders, however, spring also means the frustration of learning or relearning warbler songs. When it comes to birding with our ears, almost everyone—including us—is at a much lower level than when birding with our eyes. A big part of this problem is there’s never been any consistent system for studying or learning songs.

This spring we encourage you to try again, but this time with a system that can help you describe and remember what you’re hearing. By using a few simple, objective terms, you can understand the structure and quality of a song, and identify what’s unique about it. We’ll describe it here and show how to use it to identify 3 great warbler sounds of spring. (You can also download our guide on how to recognize 8 warbler songs.)

When You Listen to a Song, Ask These 3 Simple Questions

The Warbler Guide system is based on a simple idea: if you can accurately and objectively describe a sound, you can identify it. As a bonus, when you describe a song you pay closer attention to its details, and it becomes easier to recognize.

One reason why birders can identify birds by sight is that we have a whole vocabulary for it: words like “eyeline,” “streaking,” “wingbars,” “upperparts.” But how to describe a song? We might describe it as “sweet” or “rough” or “dark,” but these words mean different things to different people. Or we might focus on the melody, like we would with music. The problem there is that many birds don’t have a consistent melody—try memorizing the constantly changing song of a Northern Mockingbird, for example.

So instead, we’ve developed three simple questions that will separate most warbler songs, and many other bird songs: sound quality, pitch trend, and number of sections. Describe these aspects of the song, and then turn to either the Warbler Guide book or Warbler Guide app to quickly narrow down your choices. (Note: For more, see How to Listen to Warbler Songs, in The Warbler Guide. The Warbler Guide app is currently iOS only; an Android version is planned.)

Question 1: What is the Sound Quality of the Song?

We use a few simple terms to describe sound quality in a song: Buzzy, Clear, and Trilled. To help us visualize sounds, we use a very useful tool called a spectrogram. These show you time from left to right and pitch from low to high (more about how to read spectrograms).

spectogram images of buzzy, clear and trilledBuzzy   Like a bee – a good example would be Black-throated Blue Warbler song.

Clear Something you could whistle. Cardinals have a Clear song, as do Yellow Warblers.

Trilled A lot of sounds in a row that are too fast to count (technically, more than 11 sounds per second). Screech-owls sing a trill, which some birders imitate when pishing for birds. Worm-eating Warbler song is also a trill.

One small twist: sometimes a bird can sing more than one quality in a song. For example, a series of Clear elements followed by a Buzz: we’d call that Partly Buzzy.

Question 2: What Is the Pitch Trend of the Song?

pitch profile
Is the overall pitch of the song Rising, Falling, Steady, or does it move up and down (Variable)? Note that here we’re looking for the overall trend of the song, so if there’s a slight fall in pitch but otherwise the song is mostly rising, then it would still be considered a Rising song.

Question 3: How Many Sections Does the Song Have?

bird songs with one, two, and three sections

We break songs down into parts called Sections. A Section begins whenever there is a dramatic change in pitch or speed. Counting the number of Sections in a song can be one of the most effective ways to identify it.

Here are a few spectrograms that show a one-, two- and three-Section song. The gray bars at the bottom of each spectrogram show you where sections start and stop.

In addition to Sections, we can also talk aboutElements (the single sounds in song) and Phrases, which are groups of repeated Elements—more on that later.

That’s it! With those three questions, you can describe and separate most warbler songs. Now let’s try some examples.

Try It With a Few Songs

Song #1: Prairie Warbler

Listen to the song and compare it to the spectrogram:

Prairie Warbler

prairie warbler spectrogram

What Is the Sound Quality? This bird has a Buzzy song, which we hear when playing it. We can also see it in the spectrogram: each Element is “fuzzy,” as opposed to straight line, and that indicates a buzz.

A buzzy, rising, 1-section song means Prairie Warbler. Photo by Scott Whittle.A buzzy, rising, 1-section song means Prairie Warbler. Photo by Scott Whittle.

What Is the Pitch Trend? The overall pitch of the song is Rising, with a gradual step up in pitch between each Element.

How Many Sections Are There? We can see in the spectrogram that this bird has a 1-Section song. Don’t be fooled by the gradual rise in pitch: although the pitch is changing a little between each Element, it’s a steady change, and there is no sudden change in pitch or speed, so that makes it a single Section.

So we have a song that is Buzzy, Rising, 1-Section. If we look in the song finders in the Warbler Guide, or if we enter these three qualities into the Warbler Guide App filter, guess what? We get a single bird! That bird is Prairie Warbler.
Song #2: Wilson’s Warbler

Listen to the song and compare it to the spectrogram:

Wilson’s Warbler

spectrogram of wilson's warbler song

What Is the Sound Quality?  There are a lot of repeated Elements here, but they are relatively far apart, so they’re not too fast to count. That means this is not a Trill, but just a song with a series of Clear Elements.

A clear, falling, 1-section song: Wilson’s Warbler. Photo by Scott Whittle.A clear, falling, 1-section song: Wilson’s Warbler. Photo by Scott Whittle.

What Is the Pitch Trend? Overall this song has a Falling pitch. As a side note, you might notice a subtle shift downward in the second half of the song—that’s a good indicator for many Wilson’s songs.

How Many Sections Are There? This a simple, one-Section song.

So our final description is a Clear, Falling, 1-Section song. (One extra thing to notice is that the clear, separated notes have a sharp or staccato quality.) If you plug these characteristics into the Warbler Guide app using the filter feature, here’s the result:

demo of warbler guide app filtering feature with wilson's warbler

There are no other warblers that have 1-Section, Clear, Falling songs, so this description is diagnostic in both the East and West.
Song #3: Northern Parula
Listen to the song and compare it to the spectrogram:

Northern Parula

northern parula song spectrogram

What Is the Sound Quality?  Unlike Wilson’s, this bird makes a true Trill. We can tell it’s a Trill in the spectrogram by the series of closely packed near-vertical lines—notice that there are far more than 11 Elements per second, which indicates that it’s too fast to count. But now notice that there is a second section in the song, and that section is just a single Clear Element. Because the song has two qualities, we’ll call it Partly Trilled.

A trilled, rising, 2-section song: Northern Parula. Photo by Scott Whittle.A trilled, rising, 2-section song: Northern Parula. Photo by Scott Whittle.

What Is the Pitch Trend? The first Section of this song is clearly rising, and the second doesn’t change that much, so we’d call this a Rising song.

How Many Sections Are There? We can see two Sections here: first there is a long Trill, with a Rising pitch trend. But then there is a very different, fast, clear, up-down Element to finish the song—that’s the second Section.

So this is a Partly Trilled, Rising, 2-Section song. Once again, this song has a diagnostic combination: a Rising Trill with a clear up-down element at the end can only be Northern Parula. In fact, all of Northern Parula’s songs end with that distinct, clear, higher up-down note, which makes it a very handy diagnostic quality to know about.

Happy Warblering!

So by looking at three basic qualities—Sound Quality, Pitch Trend and Structure—we can finally make an accurate description of a song, and often find things about it that identify the bird to species.

You can use the answers in combination with our book and app to quickly find the bird you’re hearing. Even for non-warblers, applying these questions will help you hear details in songs that will make you a much more effective listener, and a much better birder! And if you’d like to learn more songs—download this guide to the songs of eight species, each of which has something diagnostic about it.

warbler guide authors tom stephenson and scott whittleTom Stephenson and Scott Whittle

Happy Warblering!

Scott Whittle and Tom Stephenson are the authors ofThe Warbler Guide and the Warbler Guide app, fromPrinceton University Press. Warbler recordings are via the Cornell Lab’s Macaulay Library.

More help learning bird songs:

Comments

  • Martha Morris

    I downloaded the 8 warbler songs but the audio doesn’t work.

    [This comment has been migrated from an earlier post version by Cornell Lab staff.]

  • Dustin

    Very cool! And helpful.

  • paula

    This is very helpful and fun!

    [This comment has been migrated from an earlier post version by Cornell Lab staff.]

  • Dorit Solomon

    Where can I find an android app for bird songs?

    [This comment has been migrated from an earlier post version by Cornell Lab staff.]

  • Jonathan B. Levine

    Wonderful! Canoeing in a Northern forest on Tuesday, I heard the trill and wished for confirmation, at least, that I was hearing a warbler. Thank you for these tools.

    [This comment has been migrated from an earlier post version by Cornell Lab staff.]

  • Dee Stelzried

    Loved this article…and, the actual recordings.

    Thank you!!

    [This comment has been migrated from an earlier post version by Cornell Lab staff.]

  • Chris Pierpoint

    Thanks – this is great guidance on how to train ourselves to listen for patterns and characteristics that help us distinguish different songsters. It’s like learning to look for the diagnostic features of a bird’s plumage and particularly useful now that it is so easy to make recordings on mobile devices and generate spectrograms. We can learn so much more about the birds around us if we are able to identify them from their songs and calls.

    [This comment has been migrated from an earlier post version by Cornell Lab staff.]

  • Emily Roth

    Thank you ! This sort of thing is very helpful.

    [This comment has been migrated from an earlier post version by Cornell Lab staff.]

  • Barbara Cunningham

    This is a huge help since we fail miserably on warbler songs. So easy to forget them over the year. If only all warblers were as easy as the ovenbird to identify! Thanks?

    [This comment has been migrated from an earlier post version by Cornell Lab staff.]

  • Barbara Appel

    What Missouri bird (Ozarks region) sings: “Timmy, Timmy, Timmy, Timmy, Timmy” 5 times in a row, over and over. All steady. Could be Jimmy.

    [This comment has been migrated from an earlier post version by Cornell Lab staff.]

  • Hugh

    Hi Martha – some PDF readers have trouble playing the embedded songs in the download. However, if you look right above the sound player you’ll see a link to listen to the clip online at our Macaulay Library. Hope this workaround helps! – Hugh

  • Paul

    My guess (and it is only a guess) would be Carolina Wren…google it.

    [This comment has been migrated from an earlier post version by Cornell Lab staff.]

  • David.

    Possibly a Carolina Wren

    [This comment has been migrated from an earlier post version by Cornell Lab staff.]

  • Hugh

    thanks to the commenters below for suggesting Carolina Wren as your songster. You can listen to the song at our All About Birds page for the species: http://allaboutbirds.org/guide/carolina_wren/sounds

  • Debra Elmore

    I have a Honey Locust Tree that is in bloom and have noticed that the tree is a favorite foraging site for warblers. Lately I have captured images of one that looks like a Cape May Warbler. Warblers are so awesome! I love capturing videos that include the Warbler songs! Last year I bought an app that allows me to sit outside and play the bird songs to compare with the real thing, it messes with the birds, but I don’t think it will harm them to have a little vocal competition.

    [This comment has been migrated from an earlier post version by Cornell Lab staff.]

  • Jennifer

    Hi Debra, you need to do this with caution. Playing calls to birds does affect them more than you might imagine. They think they have a rival intruding in their territory and use up a lot of energy and time in defence, counter singing, and it’s probably highly stressful for them.

    [This comment has been migrated from an earlier post version by Cornell Lab staff.]

  • Beverly Brown

    Yes, I am also looking for Android apps for birding, preferably downloadable from Amazon as GooglePlay can be impossible to use.

    [This comment has been migrated from an earlier post version by Cornell Lab staff.]